Cryptid Cafe Podcast
Two friends, Sarah and Michelle, discuss cryptid folklore and personal stories over coffee, rating each creature in a 'Smash or Pass' segment.
This is a classic 'two friends talking' podcast, using cryptids as a jumping-off point for casual, often humorous conversation. The hosts, Sarah and Michelle, structure each episode around a few creatures, but the show's real texture comes from their personal stories, tangents about their middle school days, and recurring bits like rating a cryptid's attractiveness. [fBsLW0IHHeo] It's less a formal cryptozoology report and more like eavesdropping on friends at a coffee shop.
“The show's most distinctive feature is its recurring 'Smash or Pass' segment, where the hosts humorously rate the physical attractiveness of the cryptid being discussed. [fBsLW0IHHeo, lqe_n6SAfj8] This, combined with deeply personal and often self-deprecating anecdotes, sets it apart from more serious cryptozoology podcasts.”
Who hosts this show
Cryptid Cafe Podcast is a conversational show hosted by friends Sarah and Michelle. [fBsLW0IHHeo] Each episode, they pour a cup of coffee and discuss the folklore, sightings, and theories behind various cryptids, from the Snallygaster of Appalachia to Black-Eyed Children. [lqe_n6SAfj8, pY43F4fC-pg] The show mixes creature deep-dives with personal anecdotes and humorous asides, like a chat between friends who happen to be into the paranormal. [fBsLW0IHHeo]
What kind of podcast
- Country
- United States
- Region
- usa
When new episodes drop
- 01Black Eyed Cryptids - Cryptid Café Podcast Episode 3Aug 23, 2025 · 48 min
- 02Appalachian Cryptids - Cryptid Café Podcast Episode 2Aug 10, 2025 · 51 min
- 03Cryptids of Southern California - Cryptid Café Podcast Episode 1Jul 5, 2025 · 45 min
Notable episodes
- 01Cryptids of Southern California - Cryptid Café Podcast Episode 1
The first episode introduces the hosts, their friendship origin story, and recurring segments like 'Smash or Pass,' establishing the show's casual, personality-driven tone.
- 02Appalachian Cryptids - Cryptid Café Podcast Episode 2
Features a deep dive into the Snallygaster, including historical accounts from the 1900s and the legend of it dying in a moonshine vat, showcasing the show's blend of research and storytelling.
- 03Black Eyed Cryptids - Cryptid Café Podcast Episode 3
Explores the unsettling lore of Black-Eyed Children and Crawlers, while also featuring a memorable personal tangent about 'chaos gardening'.
What you'll be asked on this show
This is a non-interview, two-host conversational show. Episodes begin with hosts Sarah and Michelle discussing their personal weeks and what coffee they're drinking, a nod to the 'Cafe' theme. [pY43F4fC-pg, lqe_n6SAfj8] The tone is informal and often tangential, with the hosts' friendship and shared history being central to the dynamic. [fBsLW0IHHeo]
Signature segments
- · Opening Coffee Chat
- · Smash or Pass
- · Weekly Personal Catch-up
Topics covered repeatedly
Where to find this show
Audience & reach
Based on the available episodes, the podcast does not feature sponsors or advertisements. Any potential sponsorship would likely be for direct-to-consumer brands in the lifestyle or paranormal interest space (estimated).
Subscriber and view counts are pulled live from YouTube and re-verified on a 30-day cycle. Listener estimates for the RSS feed aren't published here unless they're host-verified.
Pitch this show
c•••@•••.comFree: limited reveals · Pro: unlimited reveals + CSV export
You’re only charged when we return a verified hit.
People also ask
- Who are the hosts?
- The podcast is hosted by two friends, Sarah and Michelle, who have known each other since middle school. [fBsLW0IHHeo]
- What is the podcast's format?
- It's a conversational show where the two hosts discuss different cryptids over coffee. It is not an interview show and does not feature guests. [pY43F4fC-pg, lqe_n6SAfj8]
- Is the podcast still running?
- The podcast published three episodes in July and August 2025 and has not released a new one since, suggesting it is no longer active.
- What is 'Smash or Pass'?
- It's a recurring segment where the hosts humorously debate whether they would 'smash' (find attractive) or 'pass' on the cryptid being discussed in the episode. [fBsLW0IHHeo]
- Where can I listen to the podcast?
- The episodes are available on the Cryptid Cafe Podcast YouTube channel.
Built from the show's public RSS feed, YouTube, the host's own websites, and the cited sources below. Computed and AI-extracted fields are labelled. Facts only — no private info, no fabrication, no transcripts republished.
Sources & how this page was built
This page is AI-assisted, grounded in the public sources cited below, and host-verifiable. We publish facts only; we do not republish transcripts. If anything here is wrong, the host can claim and correct the page above.Model: gemini-2.5-pro · high confidence
Podcasts like Cryptid Cafe Podcast
DIVE Studios / 다이브 스튜디오
A media company and podcast network where K-pop idols and Korean-American artists discuss culture, careers, and personal identity.
PARANORMAL EXPERIENCE
PARANORMAL EXPERIENCE
Um podcast brasileiro de longa duração onde dois apresentadores entrevistam médiuns, mentores e especialistas sobre suas experiências paranormais e estruturas espirituais.
Saad Rashid - YouTube Automation
Saad Rashid
A Pakistani host interviews creators of 'faceless' YouTube channels, breaking down their niche strategies, AI workflows, and revenue generation.
The History Guy: History Deserves to Be Remembered
A history storyteller who narrates short, engaging videos about forgotten events and figures, typically in 15 minutes or less.
Silicon Valley Girl
Silicon Valley Girl
An entrepreneur interviews the founders and scientists building the next wave of AI to uncover practical strategies for career and business growth.
The Arena
The Arena
A daily sports debate show where 3-time NBA All-Star Gilbert Arenas and a panel of former pros give unfiltered takes on basketball news.
Shallu Nisha Podcast
Shallu Nisha
A long-form interview podcast exploring the careers and business of North Indian digital creators, artists, and entrepreneurs.
Backstage with Millionaires
Pankaj Chauhan
A weekly news show and documentary-style channel breaking down the biggest stories and trends in the Indian startup and venture capital ecosystem.